(989) 732-9288
Bennethum’s wood-paneled wine cellar and lounge

Restaurant in Gaylord, Michigan

Made in-house, from the bread to the bisque

Virtually everything is made in-house, including our Famous BNI Bread and Mushroom Bisque, in Gaylord, Michigan.

  • 01Family owned & operated

Fine dining without the compromises in health

We believe that customers should be able to enjoy a fine dining experience, without the compromises made in health when going out. We have moved away from products with preservatives, pesticides, and antibiotics. These products can have unhealthy side effects.

01Services

From the menu

Our menu is thoughtfully renewed each month, giving the kitchen room to follow the season and keep each return visit fresh.

Plated chicken with creamy sauce, pasta and red cabbage on a table

Signature Entrees

Signature-seasoned and char-grilled, including 6oz Filet Mignon and 12oz Ribeye Steak.

A bistro plate or burger served at the restaurant

Bistro Menu

BNI Burger, Crispy Panko Perch, Filet Mignon Sliders and Fettuccini Alfredo.

Amber drink over ice in a Bennethum's branded glass

Happy Hour

Half-off all drinks and $10 - $16 Small Plates from 4pm-6pm throughout the restaurant.

  • Monthly Wine Dinners

    Wines from around the world paired with seasonal, chef-curated menus.

Join us for dinner.

Call 989-732-9288 to reserve
02About

Our Story

Spanning many generations, our family has an enduring history in Hospitality. Ranging from bakeries to boarding houses to restaurants, the calling to serve has been central to us for decades.

We then envisioned a supper club-style restaurant, with a more refined menu that would feature diverse flavors, styles, and dishes inspired from around the world. This dream became Bennethum’s Northern Inn.

Timber-lined dining room with tables set for dinner, showing the family-run room
04Area

At home in Northern Michigan

3917 Old US 27 South, Gaylord, MI 49735

  • Gaylord, Michigan
05FAQ

Questions before you visit

Do I need a reservation?

Reservations are highly recommended. Call 989-732-9288 to book.

When are you open?

Tuesday – Saturday, 4:00 PM – 9:00 PM. Closed Sunday and Monday.

What should I wear?

Casual dress. All are welcome.

Do you sell gift cards?

Digital e-Gift Cards available instantly. Physical gift cards are also available in person at the restaurant during our normal business hours.

06Contact

Join us for dinner

Reservations are highly recommended.

(989) 732-9288